Pumpkin Spice Old Fashioned Recipe - Florida Dancing Juice (2024)

0 0

Jump to recipe

The Pumpkin Spice Old Fashioned is the perfect sipper for a fall evening. Mixing bourbon with homemade Pumpkin Spice Simple Syrup and finished off with a few dashes of bitters, this co*cktail will warm you up as the temperature starts to dip. This recipe supports local Florida businesses by using Florida Bourbon and Florida Cane Sugar in the simple syrup. Help support local and enjoy your Pumpkin Spice Old Fashioned.

What Ingredients Do I Need To Make A Pumpkin Spice Old Fashioned?

The Alcohol

The Whiskey: An Old Fashioned is 80% whiskey, so it is important that you choose a quality bourbon. Luckily, Florida has some fantastic bourbons to pick from. Our go to Florida whiskey for an Old Fashioned is Florida Double Cask Bourbon from St. Augustine Distillery. It goes particularly well in this Pumpkin Spice version, complimenting the baking spice notes already in the whiskey. Other great alternatives are Florida Reserve Bourbon from Timber Creek Distillery and Palm Ridge Reserve from Palm Ridge Distillery.

Recommended Florida Bourbons:

• Florida Double Cask Bourbonfrom St. Augustine Distillery
• Florida Reserve Bourbon from Timber Creek Distillery
• Palm Ridge Reserve from Palm Ridge Distillery

Get these bottles delivered right to your door by DRIZLY.Click and use code DRIZLYDEALfor$5 offof your first order.

The Mixers

The Sweetener: Our homemade Pumpkin Spice Simple Syrup is what gives this Old Fashioned co*cktail recipe a healthy dose of fall. This incredibly easy simple syrup recipe just involves simmering ground cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger and cloves with canned pumpkin, sugar and water. As well as using it in your fall co*cktail recipes you can also use it to make a Pumpkin Spice Latte or even drizzle it over your pancakes.

Recommended Simple Syrup: Homemade Pumpkin Spice Simple Syrup

The Bitters: Bitters are used in an Old Fashioned to balance out the sweetness and add complexity. Angostura Bitters are best to use for this Pumpkin Spice Old Fashioned as the spicy notes of cinnamon and clove double down on the spices used in the homemade Pumpkin Spice Simple Syrup.

Recommended Bitters: ANGOSTURA® bitters, 4 oz

What Equipment Should I Use To Make A Pumpkin Spice Old Fashioned?

You can see our full list of recommended bar equipment here.

The Glass: For this co*cktail, use an Old Fashioned glass (also called rocks glass). If you’re starting out in the world of co*cktail glassware, we’d recommend buying double Old Fashioned glasses (also called Double Rocks glasses). These are slightly larger than a single Old Fashioned glass, holding between 10-12 oz. This makes them more versatile as they allow more space for jumbo ice cubes and work great for other kinds of co*cktails.

Recommended Glass: MARQUIS By Waterford Double Old Fashioned Glasses, Set of 4

The Ice: This fall Old Fashioned is a sipper, so it’s best to use large ice cubes. The larger the cube you use the less it will dilute the drink, so you can enjoy it for longer without it becoming too watery. You can find some great (and cheap) jumbo ice cube molds on Amazon. Just be sure to check the width of your glasses to ensure that they will fit.

Recommended Ice Cube Mold: co*ckTAILOR Large Ice Mold, 6 Slot

Shaken or Stirred: Always stir an Old Fashioned. You can stir straight in the glass that you’re drinking out of, but it’s best to use a mixing glass. If you enjoy spirit forward co*cktails like an Old Fashioned, a Negroni, or a Manhattan, then get yourself a mixing glass. It’s one of our most used pieces of bar equipment.

Recommended Mixing Glass: HIWARE Thick Bottom Crystal Mixing Glass, 24 oz

We hope you enjoy our Pumpkin Spice Old Fashioned recipe below, and as always drink local and drink responsibly. Cheers!

This post contains affiliate links and we may earn a small commission when purchases of recommended products are made. This is at no additional cost to you, and every penny goes back into buying and trying more tasty Floridian tipples.

Other Florida co*cktail Recipes To Try:

Old Fashioned Floridian (Orange Old Fashioned)

Key Lime Whiskey Sour

Cosmo-floridan (Cosmopolitan)

Florida Orange Daiquiri

Southbeach fizz

Grapefruit Martini

Florida Whiskey Smash

Pineapple Margarita

Florida Orange Manhattan

Tampa Bay Breeze (Tampa Bay Rays game day co*cktail)

Tom(ahawk) Collins (FSU game day co*cktail)

The Gator (UF game day co*cktail)